I love bookstores and libraries. Honestly, I feel more at home surrounded by books than I do surrounded by people. But since becoming a Naturalistic Pagan, my trips to the bookstore have become a lot more complicated.
Every time I go into a bookstore, I visit the Paganism section, or rather, the Metaphysical/Occult section that Paganism is grouped with. I don’t know why I still do it. Hope springs eternal, I guess.
Each time I approach the Metaphysical with the hopeful expectation that this time I will find something that speaks to me. I stand there for a while, feeling embarrassed, afraid someone might see me. I look for an escape route. The Philosophy section is close by. The Psychology section even closer. Once I establish that I have plausible deniability, I relax a little and quickly peruse the books. Inevitably, though, I discover that I have once again wasted my time. There’s nothing there that speaks to what I call “Paganism”.
If you’ve visited the Paganism section of any bookstore, you know what I’m talking about. The Pagan books are sandwiched between books on UFOs and vampires on one side and books on divination on the other. And the Pagan books themselves are not much better: Lots of Wicca 101 teen witch kind of stuff. There’s usually Starhawk and Drawing Down the Moon, but I’ve long ago exhausted those resources. I always leave feeling a mixture of disappointment and embarrassment.
The truth is, the most useful (small-p) “pagan” books I have found over the years are not found in the Paganism section at all. In fact, they don’t even include the word “Pagan”.
What makes it “pagan” then? Well, that’s going to vary from person to person. But for me, pagan writing is writing that awakens my senses to the sacred in the physical world. Here’s some “pagany” books that you won’t find in the Pagan section of the bookstore, some I have read and some I want to.
What naturalistic pagan books have been an inspiration to you? Share in the comments below.
Pilgrim at Tinker Creek by Annie Dillard
I was probably destined to become Pagan the day I picked up Tinker Creek as a freshman in college. It’s so sacred to me, I still have my original copy from almost 25 years ago. Dillard has been called the “female Thoreau” and her Tinker Creek a “modern day Walden“. The book opened my eyes to many things. In fact, much of the book is about the act of seeing.
It’s study of the coexistence of beauty and horror in nature. Reading it was a step toward my understanding that the cruelty and suffering of nature (and life generally) are inseparable from its beauty and grace. When I became Pagan, I came to recognize both these sides of nature as faces of the divine. The book also introduced me to nature mysticism. In retrospect, I can see how these lessons prepared me for Paganism.
On my list of books I want to read: Refuge: An Unnatural History of Family and Place and An Unspoken Hunger: Stories from the Field by Terry Tempest Williams. Williams is a former Mormon, feminist, and environmental activist.
David Abram’s Naturalistic Animism
It’s no exaggeration to say that David Abram transformed how I understand Paganism. Abram’s thought is an example of what Bron Taylor calls “naturalistic animism”. I first read Abram’s shorter essays which can be found on the Alliance for Wild Ethics website. It was only later that I got around to reading Spell of the Sensuous and Becoming Animal.
Abram opened up the animate world to me. Whereas before, my Paganism was almost entirely inwardly focused, Abram connected my Paganism to the living, breathing world. Abram makes the case that our most immediate experience is of being immersed in an animate world, and we make the world into a world of dead objects only by artificially abstracting ourselves–our own living, breathing bodies–out of it.
This is not about the projection of consciousness or agency onto “inanimate” objects, but openness to and reciprocity with a more-than-human community which transcends the subject-object dichotomy. Practicing animism requires returning to our natural awareness of our sensorial reciprocity with the material world. I’m still working this out in practice.
On my list of books I want to read: The Handbook of Contemporary Animism edited by Graham Harvey. Harvey is a Pagan Studies scholar, but this book is a study of indigenous animism by non-Pagan scholars.
Braiding Sweetgrass by Robin Wall Kimmerer
I was introduced to Robin Wall Kimmerer by NPR’s On Being. She is a member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation and Professor of Environmental and Forest Biology at the State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry. In her book, Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge and the Teachings of Plants (2013), Kimmerer combines the wisdom of her indigenous heritage with her scientific training.
Kimmerer writes about the surprising (at me, at least) mechanization of nature in contemporary botanical science, to which she contrasts indigenous cultures which teaches us about our reciprocity with the natural world. She also discusses our objectification of other-than-human beings through our language. Rather than describing other-than-human living beings as “it”, Kimmerer suggests using the pronoun “ki”. She is also the author of Gathering Moss: A Natural and Cultural History of Mosses, which is on my list.
On my list of books I want to read: The Secret Teachings of Plants: The Intelligence of the Heart in the Direct Perception of Nature by
To a God Unknown by John Steinbeck
Although not explicitly Pagan, To a God Unknown is one of the most (small-p) pagan stories I have ever read. It tells the story of a man, Joseph, who comes to California to farm. He believes that a tree on the farm embodies the spirit of his deceased father, and he believes that the prosperity of the farm is connected to the life of the tree. Joseph talks to the tree and makes sacrifices to it.
Following a very “pagan” fiesta, one of Joseph’s brothers, a devout Christian, kills the tree. A drought follows. I don’t want to spoil the end, but those familiar with Frazer’s Golden Bough will understand the meaning.
On my list of books I want to read: Jitterbug Perfume by Tom Robbins.
John Muir’s writings
John Muir was an early conservationist and the founder of the Sierra Club. He wrote extensively about his exploration of the Sierra Nevada mountains of California, merging his inspiring personal experience of the sublimity of the natural world with a call for direct action to preserve wild nature. His activism helped to preserve Yosemite Valley and other wilderness areas as national parks.
Like the Transcendentalists, Muir believed that nature was the revelation of the divine and direct contact with nature a sacrament. Muir often used religious language to describe his experience of the mountains, often drawn from the Bible. In some places, he seems more of a pantheists, or even an animist. Muir wrote about the interconnection of all things, a common pagan theme. He believed that direct contact with wilderness was spiritually nourishing and an antidote to civilization.
Muir wrote several books and there are lots of books about Muir. I recommend starting with The Contemplative John Muir: Spiritual Quotations from the Great American Naturalist or Meditations of John Muir: Nature’s Temple.
On my list of books I want to read: Anything by John Burroughs. Maybe I’ll start with The Art of Seeing Things: Essays by John Burroughs or Harvest of a quiet eye: The natural world of John Burroughs.
An Altar in the World: A Geography of Faith by Barbara Brown Taylor
An Altar in the World is about finding the sacred in the mundane world–something that is central to my understanding of paganism. Taylor approaches spirituality from the belief that there is no spirituality apart from our bodily life here on earth. Therefore, she finds spirituality in the practice of attention to the most human of activities: making bread, making love, digging in the earth, and hanging clothes on a line.
Taylor is a Christian, and she writes from a that perspective. But it is an inclusive Christianity, which does not exclude the possibility of genuine atheist spirituality. Though her spiritual practices arise from her Christianity, Taylor seems very “pagan”. In fact, the first story she tells from the Christian Bible is one of the most “pagan” parts of the Bible: When Jacob wakes from a divine dream, he sets a stone upright in the place and pours oil over it, to mark it as the house of God.
The book consists of 12 chapters, each of which addresses a spiritual practice. Several of these practices have ancient origins, but Taylor presents them as arising out of everyday human experience. For example, for Taylor, the Sabbath is simply the practice of saying “no” and prayer is the practice of being present to the divine. Other practices Taylor describes include the practice of walking on the earth (groundedness), the practice of getting lost (wilderness), the practice of encountering others (community), and the practice of carrying water (physical labor). I think most of Taylor’s practices boil down to being present in our bodies and paying attention to the physical world. Each of these practices is, for Taylor, “an altar in the world” where people can meet the divine that, in her words, “some call God”.
On my list of books I want to read: Grounded: Finding God in the World–A Spiritual Revolution by Diana Butler Bass.
Mary Oliver, Rilke, and other poets
UU columnist Doug Muder has defined spirituality as the “awareness of the gap between what you can experience and what you can describe.” Thus, I think, poetry is a natural medium for spirituality. There’s lots of good poetry that evokes the experience of the sacred in the mundane, but two of my favorites poets are Mary Oliver and Rilke.
Oliver’s poems “Wild Geese”, “Bone”, and “One or Two Things” have inspired some of the rituals which are a part of my personal practice. And some of Rilke’s poems have become regular “prayers” for me, like Book of Hours I 25 and Book of Hours, I 59.
Other important poems for me have been e.e. cummings’ “Oh Sweet Spontaneous”, Algernon Swinburnes’ Hertha, and Teilhard Chardin’s Hymn of the Universe (not a poem, per se, but definitely poetic). And last but not least is Wordsworth, who admits, in “The World is Too Much With Us”, that he would “rather be a Pagan”. His poem “Tintern Abbey” expresses the feeling of lateral transcendence that I have experienced in nature.
Other “pagan” poets I want to read more of are the Romantics like Schiller, Holderlin, and Byron, and contemporary poets Wendell Berry, David Whyte, and Adrienne Rich.
What naturalistic pagan books have been an inspiration to you? Share in the comments below.
About the Author
John Halstead is a native of the southern Laurentian bioregion and lives in Northwest Indiana, near Chicago. He is one of the founders of 350 Indiana-Calumet, which works to organize resistance to the fossil fuel industry in the Region. John was the principal facilitator of “A Pagan Community Statement on the Environment”. He strives to live up to the challenge posed by the statement through his writing and activism. John has written for numerous online platforms, including Patheos, Huffington Post, PrayWithYourFeet.org, Gods & Radicals. He is Editor-at-Large of HumanisticPaganism.com. John also edited the anthology, Godless Paganism: Voices of Non-Theistic Pagans. He is also a Shaper of the Earthseed community which can be found at GodisChange.org.
Great list! The poetry of Robert Lax inspires a couple of my current devotions. He was a Christian, a close friend of Thomas Merton, but his poems are so spare and yet so mysterious that they transcend the problems I have with Christianity.
Field guides are indispensable to my practice: guides for local birds, flowers, insects, hiking trails.
There’re some popular health books out right now that strike me as small p pagan. For example, Go Wild: Eat Fat, Run Free, Be Social, and Follow Evolution’s Other Rules for Total Health and Well-Being, by John J. Ratey and Richard Manning. There’re several significant problems with this book, but it’s an easy read, and as a first approach to assessing and improving lifestyle factors, it’s interesting and helpful.
I continue to object to the paternalistic bashing of Wiccans and “teen witches.” Teen witchery empowers young women and young people from other historically oppressed groups to consider that they have they ability to shape the world. Wicca may not be meaningful to you, as a white, well-educated, cis-gender, straight guy, but why cut those already oppressed people and their practices down? It’s not hurting you. And in case a feminist critique isn’t enough to move you, here’s a writerly one: you could cut the first four paragraphs of this post, and it would be stronger for it.
Regarding teen witch books: Of course they have their place. Reading books about (what turned out to be largely false) matriarchal prehistory was a healing experience for me, because it helped me imagine a different, non-patriarchal future. My objection isn’t to those books, but to their dominance of the Pagan section of the bookstore.
Excellent recommendations, I’ll have to check them out thanks!
Wonderful list of books, including a couple I haven’t read yet. The Spell of the Sensuous is truly a life-changing book.
I echo Anna caution against dismissal of the teen witch stuff. While it is, naturally, pretty juvenile (“OOOoooo! We can be WITCHES!”), it’s a portal to what can be a lifelong and meaningful path.
The problem I have is with the turn-the-crank stuff that is obviously only there because the author needed another book in print to keep making money. Invented lore, largely. I’m sure you know what I mean. I neither need nor want a book about every damned individual ritual tool, and as my tradition is modern and forward-looking, stuff about “ancient paths” (real or imagined) is irrelevant to me.
I encourage you to check out the poetry of Robinson Jeffers, H. D. (Hilda Doolittle), Sarah Lindsay, and Gary Snyder. I think you’ll enjoy them.
Oh, and Prodigal Summer, by Barbara Kingsolver. Desert Solitaire and Down the River by Edward Abbey.
And, strange as it may seem, Snow Falling on Cedars, by David Guterson. The book is filled with the presence of the elements, with climate and snow and sea. And it’s about justice, and tolerance, and the struggle we have for both.
Thank you for this list.
Might I also recommend Sharon Blackie’s work?
I’m currently reading If Women Rose Rooted and it is breathtaking. She has a new one out that I recently ordered, I’m just waiting for the shipping from the UK. It can be found here: https://www.bookdepository.com/Enchanted-Life-Sharon-Blackie/9781910463888
Reblogged this on The Allergic Pagan and commented:
What naturalistic pagan books have been an inspiration to you?
Ohhh! I love this list! I’ll have to check some of them out.
Also, Walt Whitman’s poetry has this same spark, particularly “Song of Myself.”
I’m always surprised at how many people don’t get the part of nature that you call the cruelty and suffering/the beauty and the horror. I think some of it is holdover the Levant, and most people’s view of nature created by a benevolent god. But the universe is filled with unimaginable violence, which can still manage to be awe inspiring. (I think this is what James Joyce called the secret cause – though it has been a VERY long time since college.)
The beauty and the horror of the volcanoes in Hawaii. In photographs of storms right before a tornado. And in so many other places.
Thanks for the reading list – some of those I haven’t read.
I really loved this article. It spoke to me because I have been disappointed by many “Pagan” books. My largest complaint is that the authors are not writers and do not seem to have the needs of the reader in mind. I have placed nearly all of these books on my reading list.
Great list. I would add “All Things Shining” by Hubert Dreyfus and Sean Dorrance Kelly (lit crit, philosophy, kind of atheopagan); The Art of Conversation with the Genius Loci by Barry Patterson (ecopagan, poetic engagement with nature and science).
If you want a book on Wicca that isn’t the same old 101 material, but engages with nature, ecology/environment, science, LGBT, and social justice plus includes atheopagans, might I suggest my own books “All acts of love and pleasure: inclusive Wicca”, “Dark Mirror: the inner work of witchcraft”, and “The Night Journey: witchcraft as transformation”.